Brad is on the roll of solicitors of England & Wales but does not hold a practising certificate and does not provide legal advice.
Updated June 2026 · England & Wales
Construction projects rarely run in a straight line. Materials go missing, subcontractors cause damage, weather intervenes, and sometimes a finished job throws up a defect years later. When something goes wrong, the insurance policy you took out at the start of the project becomes one of the most important documents on site.
I'm Brad Askew, and I've spent years working at the intersection of law and technology, helping people navigate UK legal processes without drowning in jargon. This guide walks through how construction insurance claims actually work in England and Wales, what the main policies cover, how to handle the claims process sensibly, and what your options are if an insurer turns you down.
It's written for contractors, developers, consultants, and anyone else who needs to understand the landscape before a dispute lands on their desk.
Overview
A construction insurance claim is a formal request made to an insurer for payment or indemnity under the terms of a policy tied to a construction project. The policy itself is a commercial contract, and the claim is how you ask the insurer to honour that contract after a loss, incident, or allegation.
In the UK, construction insurance is not a single product. It's a layered set of policies that different parties on a project carry, often overlapping, sometimes with gaps between them. A contractor may hold Contractors All Risks cover, a consultant will typically carry Professional Indemnity, and most parties involved in the works will hold Public Liability.
Each policy responds to a different kind of risk, has its own triggers, and comes with its own notification rules. Understanding which policy responds to which event, and reading the wording carefully, is half the battle when a claim arises.
Key steps
Read the policy before you need it. Pull out the schedule, the wording, and any endorsements. Note the insured perils, the excess, the limit of indemnity, the notification clause, and any conditions precedent. Conditions precedent matter because breaching one can void cover entirely, even if the loss is otherwise legitimate.
Notify your insurer promptly and in writing. Most construction policies require notification within a specific window and in a particular form. Ring the broker, follow up in writing the same day, and keep copies of everything. Late notification is one of the most common reasons insurers raise coverage issues, so treat this step as time-critical.
Preserve and gather evidence. Take photographs, secure the site where safe to do so, keep damaged materials, and obtain witness accounts while memories are fresh. Collect contracts, programmes, site diaries, RAMS, delivery notes, and any correspondence that shows what happened and when. Strong contemporaneous evidence almost always strengthens a claim.
Engage cooperatively with the loss adjuster. The insurer will usually appoint a loss adjuster to investigate. Be responsive, provide what they reasonably ask for, and keep a paper trail of every exchange. You're entitled to be accurate and measured, but not to speculate. If a question falls outside your knowledge, say so rather than guessing.
Escalate properly if the claim is denied or undervalued. Ask for the decision in writing with reasons, check those reasons against the policy wording, and consider whether the refusal is actually sound. Options from there can include internal complaints procedures, the Financial Ombudsman Service in eligible cases, or court proceedings for larger commercial disputes.
Q What does Contractors All Risks insurance actually cover?
Contractors All Risks, usually shortened to CAR, is a combined policy that typically covers physical loss or damage to the permanent and temporary works during construction, along with plant, tools, and materials on site. Many policies bolt on third-party liability cover too. The exact scope varies between insurers, so the schedule and wording need to be read carefully rather than assumed.
Q Is Professional Indemnity insurance compulsory for construction consultants?
It isn't compulsory by statute for all consultants, but it's often required under professional body rules, client appointments, and framework agreements. Architects regulated by ARB and members of bodies like RICS and CIOB generally must hold minimum levels of PI cover. In practice, most clients will not engage a consultant who can't evidence appropriate professional indemnity insurance.
Q How long do I have to notify a construction insurance claim?
The notification period depends entirely on your policy wording. Some policies require notice 'as soon as reasonably practicable', others specify a set number of days. Professional Indemnity policies usually run on a claims-made basis, meaning the claim or circumstance must be notified during the policy period. Missing the window can give the insurer grounds to decline, so always check and act quickly.
Q What is the Insurance Act 2015 and why does it matter here?
The Insurance Act 2015 reformed commercial insurance law in the UK. It introduced a duty of fair presentation of the risk at placement, reshaped the remedies available to insurers for non-disclosure or misrepresentation, and changed how policy warranties operate. For construction clients, it means the information you gave when taking out or renewing the policy can become central if the insurer later questions cover.
Q My insurer has denied my claim. What can I do?
Start by asking for the denial in writing, with the specific policy provisions relied on. Compare those reasons to the wording and the facts. Use the insurer's internal complaints process first. For smaller commercial policyholders that meet the eligibility criteria, the Financial Ombudsman Service can consider complaints. Larger disputes are usually resolved through negotiation, mediation, or court proceedings.
Q Does Public Liability insurance cover defective workmanship?
Generally no. Public Liability responds to injury to third parties or damage to third-party property caused by your operations, not to the cost of redoing work that wasn't done properly. Defective workmanship is usually excluded. Claims arising from design or advice errors tend to fall under Professional Indemnity, while damage to the works themselves may sit under a CAR policy.
Q Can I claim on more than one policy for the same loss?
Sometimes, yes. A single incident can trigger more than one policy, for example where both a contractor's CAR policy and a subcontractor's liability policy respond. Most policies contain 'other insurance' or contribution clauses that govern how insurers share the loss. It's worth identifying every potentially responsive policy early and notifying each insurer to preserve your position.
Construction policies are dense, and a denied or disputed claim can quickly feel overwhelming when you're also trying to keep a project moving. An experienced legal adviser can help you think through your position based on what you describe on the call, so you have a clearer sense of your options before you take the next step.
✓Plain-English answers to your specific questions about the claim
✓Practical perspective on your situation based on what you describe
✓A clearer view of what to watch out for in your circumstances
✓Help thinking through your next steps with the insurer
Personal call · For information only · Independent advisers
Written & reviewed by
Brad Askew Solicitor (non-practising)
Brad is on the roll of solicitors of England & Wales but does not hold a practising certificate and does not provide legal advice. LegalDocuments.co.uk is not a law firm and does not provide regulated legal advice.
This article is for general information only. It is a tool to help you find your way — not legal advice, and not a substitute for speaking to a qualified adviser about your situation.